Overpayments by benefits programs and mandatory paybacks can be avoided with monthly reports of income by consumers

—by Matthew K. Weiland and Paul M. Kubek

Here's a situation you want to avoid. You're working with a person who has been receiving cash benefits (non-earned income) for disability from the Social Security Administration (SSA). He gets a job and stops coming into the mental-health agency for a few years. One day, he shows up with a letter from SSA informing him that he is required to pay back some benefits—$27,000 worth.

Steve Shober, BS, LSW, recounts this story from his experience as a vocational specialist and job coach in hopes that other service providers might help consumers avoid such a shocking situation. This is a cautionary tale of non-reporting, a parable of sorts. Here are the take-home tips:

  • People who receive cash benefits from Social Security programs (e.g., SSI, SSDI) are required to report earned-income from their paychecks to Social Security.
  • Not reporting income to Social Security can create some of the most panicked moments in a consumer's recovery and exacerbate symptoms.
  • Encourage consumers to report their income from jobs every month, so it becomes a regular routine. This will prevent the overpayment of benefits by Social Security to consumers and, thus, mandatory paybacks.
  • Remind consumers regularly to submit their reports.

The Conversation

This is one installment in a collection of stories from conversations with Steve Shober, BS, LSW, about the importance of benefits planning. Steve is a former vocational specialist, job coach, and benefits counselor who works as a consultant and trainer at the Ohio Supported Employment Coordinating Center of Excellence (SE CCOE), an initiative of the Center for Evidence-Based Practices at ÐÇ¿Õ´«Ã½.


A Cautionary Tale of Non-Reporting (3m, 43s)

This man had to pay back $27,000 of cash benefits to Social Security but did not have the money to do so. It's a story that has a resolution, but it's a situation that can and should be avoided. A waiver helped resolve this situation but not without a series of denials and appeals.

(right-click and 'Save As')


Sign Off (0m, 44s)

A production of the Center for Evidence-Based Practices at ÐÇ¿Õ´«Ã½â€”a partnership of the Mandel School of Applied Social Sciences at Case and the Department of Psychiatry at the Case School of Medicine.

(right-click and 'Save As')


Benefits Planning Series

Get a list of all Benefits Planning eConsults.


Matthew K. Weiland, MA, is senior writer and producer and Paul M. Kubek, MA, is director of communications at the Center for Evidence-Based Practices at ÐÇ¿Õ´«Ã½â€”a partnership of the Mandel School of Applied Social Sciences at Case and the Department of Psychiatry at the Case School of Medicine.